Cumberland Roofing

How to Determine Steel Roof Damage

Home  >>  Roofing Blogs  >>  How to Determine Steel Roof Damage

How to Determine Steel Roof Damage

On February 8, 2017, Posted by , In Roofing Blogs, With No Comments

Most metal roof systems have passed UL 2218 Impact Resistance testing at the Class IV degree — its most severe level. As a result, homeowners in half-inclined states who choose metal roofing may be eligible for discounts on their insurance premiums.

One BIG advantage to metal roofing is the fact that it doesn’t lose its impact resistance as it ages. Contrary to other roofing materials, the metal will resist hail the same in 50 or more years as it does when it is new.

They recently had the golf ball and slightly bigger hail through the region of the country and they haven’t seen one metal roof that needed to be replaced. Nonetheless, several conventional shingle roofs as well as siding installations needed to be replaced.

Some metal roofs are made with very textured finishes. If by chance, a real whopper storm came through, these textured products can last some little indentations and they’ll simply blend in with the original texturing.

Many metal roof systems do carry guarantees with hail protection, including coverage that the coatings on the surface of the metal will never be damaged. Furthermore, some systems are easily fixed if a whopper thunderstorm does come through and result in damage. (At that point, of course, practically all other roofs in the area will need complete replacement.)

You will locate metal roofing on all types of industrial, commercial, and residential buildings in New Zealand, that’s because metal roofing is an ideal choice for property owners, for a number of motives. Ease of setup, energy efficiency, hardy, and a wide selection of color aesthetics are excellent reasons to have a metal roof installed, although, eventually repairs are desired as nothing lasts forever, including high-quality metal roofing sheets.

Just as with other roofing materials, metal roof sheets have to be maintained to get the most out of them. Routine care and inspection of a metal roof can raise its longevity and reduced repair costs as the year’s pass. But, there might come a time when steel roof damage is discovered, and at that time, determining when to fix and when to re-roof needs to create.

See: Pros and Cons of a Flat Roofing Systems

Why Determining when to Repair and when to Re-roof is Significant

Although steel roof sheets are much better than shingles as roofing material, these do eventually wear with age and have to be repaired or replaced, if they are worn or damaged enough. Determining whether repairs are needed or re-roofing is mandatory should be proposed first by a professional steel roofing business, but finally, it is the property owners final decision.

While fixing a metal roof is usually much less expensive than re-roofing as an alternative, it really is just a temporary solution in lots of cases. Alloy roofing sheets can last decades if kept consistently and when repairs are made when damage is found. But when rust and corrosion take root, re-roofing is usually guided because it will save cash in comparison to always needing to make roof repairs as a short-term option, especially when holes begin to form.

Patching Holes or Re-roofing?

When holes start to appear it’s usually because corrosion and rust have grown on the metal sheets, either as a consequence of damage or as years pass from wear. When this occurs, patching holes can stop leaking, briefly, but the underlining problem, corrosion, and rust remain. Getting your steel roof scrutinized is the only approach to be aware of the wellness of your roof and whether only sections have to be fixed, mended, or replaced, or, whether re-roofing is the very best solution.
Occasionally, only a section of a roof can be replaced, rather than re-roofing the entire roof, however, a steel roof professional will be able to advocate what is the best option.

What’s Hail and How Can it Form?

Hail is a kind of precipitation occurring when air updrafts (up air currents) in thunderstorms take raindrops into the upper-level clouds where temperatures are below freezing. A tiny particle of ice types around some kind of nucleus. It could possibly be a miniature ice crystal, a spec of dust, frozen raindrop or something different.

The frozen ice particle then drops within the cloud back below freezing temperatures, where it picks up more moisture from rain drops and water vapor. Finally, it gets captured in a different updraft and freezes again.

The stronger the updrafts, the more a hailstone circulates up and down developing larger and larger until gravitation no longer allows it to stay lofted.
At that stage, the hail drops toward the earth, where it can inflict damage on individuals or property.

Hail Damages to Metal Roofs

Metal Roof Kinds

Metal is used as a roof covering substance in several forms, including metal panels, and formed metal shingles and tiles.

Metal Panels

Long, narrow metal panels are usually installed up and down the roof and overlap in a fashion much like shingles. They may have one of a number of seam types. Hail may dent metal panel roofs but seldom causes functional damage because the panels are well-supported by direct contact with the substrate over most of the surface, leaving them exceptionally resistant to denting by hail. When metal panel roofs endure practical damage, it’s commonly brought on by hail damaging a seam or trim, which might subsequently allow moisture to enter the roof construction.

Practical Damage

Potential scenarios during which purposeful damage may happen include severe hail damage to particularly vulnerable components, such as seams, ridge and hip caps, gabled end trimming and eave trim, and any location where panel edges meet, and where damage may allow moisture invasion and leakage or lower the wind resistance of the affected region.

Sheet metal is formed into various roofing parts made to mimic other kinds of roofing materials, for example, shingles, slate, and tile.

Metal shingles are about the size of asphalt composition strip shingles, several times broader than they’re tall. They’re also generally hollow, so their resistance to impact depends on the gauge of the sheet metal from which they’re made. Because folds in the field of the unit may add strength, impact resistance is, in addition, affected to some degree by the formed profile.

Metal shingle roofs are damaged more easily than metal panels since they normally rest on only the substrate along their borders, leaving most of each shingle unsupported. Indentations from hail are visible in the photo below, although they aren’t serious enough to be called functional damage.

Cosmetic Damage

Aesthetic damage is generally not paid for by insurance companies, although this changes determined by the insurance company, how the policy is written, and other conditions. There are exceptions.

The last decision on whether to cover the damage is created by the insurance company claims adjuster. It depends, to some degree, on the way in which the coverage is composed. A costly copper roof damaged in a highly visible area could be covered to some degree because observable damage may give rise to a loss in home value because of the high visibility of the affected roof gradients.

Because of this, if, during the review, you see damage to a metal roof that seems to be hail-related but is just aesthetic damage, you need to photograph it and mention it in your report. It’s best to say that it appears to be hail damage because you don’t know for sure unless you saw the damage really created.

Wind Damage to Metal Roofs

Metal Panels

Metal panel roofs that are of top quality and correctly installed typically do well in high wind events. In the event the edges are well-fastened and appropriate trim is used, the wind has very little opportunity to go into space beneath the panels, which minimizes the likelihood of inflation.

The smooth surface of the panels promotes great laminar flow and helps limit turbulence, each of which reduces the possibility of the metal roofing components being pulled loose and blown off, distorted or displaced.

Areas with missing fasteners, or rake and eave edges that have lost or improperly installed parts, are the most likely to suffer damage from the wind. Panels that lose trimming at borders or eaves may suffer damage from inflation.

Metal Shingles

Metal shingles commonly have a low profile and generally do well in wind occasions. Most are fastened on top as well as interlock along their sides, and a few kinds additionally fasten in the rear, which helps fix them against the wind.
The wind resistance of metal shingles depends upon their layout, profile, and installation.

Galvalume Steel Roof Hail Damage

Metallurgical failure analysis and damage assessment were requested after extreme hail damaged Galvalume coated steel roofing in Grayson County, Texas. The hail was reported to be 6-8 inches in diameter.

Segments of roofing panels, which exhibited hail damage from light to heavy, were removed for examination. A sampling of hail damage from various roof panels is shown in the photographs below. For size reference, the black insert cartons defining the ultimate sample areas are about 33 inches.

A scanning electron microscope (SEM) evaluation of numerous roof samples was conducted. Scanning electron micrographs that are pictures from the scanning electron microscope, of the sample denoted A2 at magnifications of 50x and 300x are revealed in the photos below.

Energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS), which is a chemical analysis within a defined area, was conducted within the carton denoted in the photograph below.

The chemical analysis within the crack shown a sizable concentration of iron (Fe). These results suggested the cracks caused by the extreme hail had penetrated the Galvalume steel coating to the steel substructure.

The effect of the cracking in the Galvalume roof coating will probably be unknown until sufficient time has elapsed to ascertain if the cracked Galvalume surface had enough chemical action to protect the steel roofing subsurface from concentrated pitting corrosion.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

[iframe src="" width="1" height="1"]